Comparison of Wet Abrasive Blast (WAB) and Dry Abrasive Blast Cleaning

There are many methods of wet abrasive blast cleaning (WAB) in surface preparation to remove coatings.
Since the 1980’s, Carolina Equipment and Supply Co. (CESCO) has been supplying WAB equipment along with recycling methods.
Recently CESCO sent me two youtubes to directly compare traditional dry abrasive blast cleaning and Wet Abrasive Blast Cleaning using their AquaMiser (TM) equipment. I would like to share the youtubes with you.
===
Dry Blast (Traditional Abrasive Blast Cleaning) Surface Preparation
Parameters: 375 cfm compressor at 100 psi using a # 8 venturi nozzle

The panel was 54” x 28” (137 cm x 71 cm) (10.5 sq. feet) and was coated with an epoxy primer and poly urethane topcoat.

Abrasive: Dupont Starblast 101 using 18 lbs per minute at a cost of $.22 cents per lb (total abrasive cost $23.76)
Time: 6 minutes
Dry Abrasive Blast Cleaning
===
Aqua Miser Wet Abrasive Blast Cleaning (Surface Preparation)
Parameters: 35,000 psi 3 gpm using the F40 Abrasive Fan Gun with a 15 degree tip

The panel was 54” x 28” (137 cm x 71 cm) (10.5 sq. feet) and was coated with an epoxy primer and poly urethane topcoat.

Abrasive: Dupont Starblast 101 using 2lbs per minute at a cost of $.22 cents per lb (total abrasive cost was $1.32)
Time: 2 minutes 43 seconds
Wet Abrasive Blast Cleaning (CESCO)

Pipeline Integrity Congress – ReCap

The attendees and speakers at the Pipeline Integrity Congress covered all aspects of crude pipeline transport.  There was a mix of academics, operators, and contractors- or suppliers, each of us with a different viewpoint.  As typical of a conference organized by European managers, there was time to hear a talk, discuss it, then have a break in the exhibition hall with refreshments, then convene for a few talks, break for a sponsored lunch, have talks and tak a break, have talks and discussion, and have a sponsored supper.  It made for an exchange of ideas.  The group was large enough to fill the room, but not so large that you couldn’t get with each other.  As usual, I knew perhaps 1-2 people when I got there, but left with business cards.  The equipment and techniques, i.e. the use of a combination of HP WaterJetting and Ultra High Pressure WaterJetting to remove the coatings prior to conventional abrasive blast cleaning to get back to the “traditional” surface – I first saw in Wharton Texas in the 1980’s.  Cleaning and inspecting and physically looking at long sections of pipelines is not practiced in the USA.  We look at thousands of small bell holes or short sections.  I assert that these pipelines are old; at some point you will have to look at them.  Why not now? Why let them continue to leak or, in the worst case, blow up.  Let’s get the best of both worlds- removal of coatings by WaterJetting as the pre-cleaning, followed by clean abrasive blasting.  Slowly but surely this equipment [ that originated in Canada] and technique migrated to Canada for the Trans Canadian Pipeline, and to Russia and Europe.  My co-author Sidney Taylor spends most of his time overseas, not in the USA.

The university professors spoke about how you can see inhibitors line up on the surface, and what makes them break down, or what is the beginning of corrosion, and how to stop it.  AC Corrosion was presented along with Cathodic Disbondment.  The techniques of pigging, treatment with biocides, and maintenance of rectifiers and transducers- what is the best potential to maintain;  the theft of buried copper strips for anodic protection, all came under discussion as well as lots of comments about PHMSA auditing and regulation.

 

The Only Pipeline Integrity Congress Focused Specifically on Crude Comes To Houston 19-20 Nov 2014

 

This year’s inaugural Crude Pipeline Asset Integrity Congress is the only event designed specifically for crude oil pipelines.

With the continual emergence of new shale plays across the US, crude production has continued to soar and crude takeaway capacity with it. Tens of thousands of miles of crude pipelines now traverse the United States and Canada and as pipeline infrastructure continues to expand at this rapid pace, it has become absolutely imperative for pipeline operators to maintain the highest level of integrity in these pipelines to maintain flow rates, avoid hazardous leaks and expensive repairs.

Crude pipelines and facilities require specific tools and considerations for maintenance.In order to deliver operators with the most comprehensive understanding of the latest, most effective integrity management tools relevant to their operations, solutions designed specifically for crude pipelines need to be presented.

“This is the only conference focused specifically on crude oil pipelines and 100% focused on the pipeline operator’s experience. We’ve put together a select group of pipeline operators and academics to deliver practical case studies on optimizing the main pipeline integrity plan. This is really a very valuable opportunity for operators to learn from each other and apply that knowledge to their day to day work.” Says Diana Franco, Conference Director.

Kinder Morgan, BP, ExxonMobil, Centurion Pipeline, Buckeye Partners and more are also confirmed to speak at the conference on 19-20 November in Houston.

 

For more information, please visit the event website here:

http://www.crude-pipeline-asset-integrity-2014.com/

TEST PROTOCOL for CORROSION INHIBITORS OR SALT CLEANERS for FLASH RUST

This is a Test Protocol for Corrosion Inhibitors or Cleaners for Flash Rust.

Prepared by Lydia Frenzel from a specific Proprietary Inhibitor and Cleaner manufacturer’s sheet. Most of the manufacturers have letters or tests results from specific coatings manufacturers. If you contact me, I will send you the link to the source material.

OBJECTIVE: This document provides guidelines for testing Proprietary Inhibitor and Cleaner used according to its manufacturer’s instructions. These test guidelines are necessary because applicable ASTM test procedures specifically require that tests be conducted in a manner consistent with the manufacturer=s instructions for use of the product tested. Since the performance of the product is application sensitive, this step by step test procedure should be helpful in the evaluation of its performance in various surface preparation methods.

Background: This gives the specific background of the Proprietary Inhibitor and Cleaner.

TEST PROCEDURE: Panel Preparation Steel test panels should be used when testing for rust formation. The size of the panels may vary but generally are 3″ x 5″ x 0.25″. Ten panels per coating is generally adequate to test for both salt removal and coating adhesion. All panels, with the exception of the control panel, should be immersed for 100 hours in an 8-10% weight by weight (w/w) sodium chloride solution to accelerate rust development. The control panel which was not immersed in salt water solution will establish the baseline reading for salts and other contaminants levels. In addition to the control panel, leave one test panel out of the blast sequence to measure the salt levels deposited after 100 hours of immersion. The other eight panels will be blasted to SSPC-SP10 (NACE 2)(Near White) using the either the water-abrasive blasting method or the dry blast method.

For Water-Abrasive Blasting: Per manufacturer’s recommendation for water-abrasive blasting, Proprietary Inhibitor and Cleaner should be used in both the blast and the wash down cycles. In the blast cycle the product can be injected into the blast stream by using an injection pump at low dilution of 50:1 ratio of Proprietary Inhibitor and Cleaner to water or higher (as high as 250:1) only with potable water.

Pre-mixing of the product is also acceptable as long as the mixing ratio is the same (50 parts potable water or higher with 1 part Proprietary Inhibitor and Cleaner or higher).

In the wash down cycle in water-abrasive blasting it is critical that the mixing ratio not exceed 100:1, because the wash down cycle is the final rinse of the surface. Wash down not only cleans contaminants that were present before the blast but also removes shattered abrasive particles embedded in the surface profile during the blast cycle. These embedded particles have a potential to form rust on the surface because they are wet, may contain chlorides, sulfates, and other contaminants, and will attract oxygen in the air. Therefore, to get these particles out of the surface profile and achieve a perfectly cleaned surface a wash down is necessary.

Wash down as defined by the manufacturer should have at least 500 psi pressure @ 1-3 g.p.m. of water (potable) mixed with Proprietary Inhibitor and Cleaner at a 50:1 to 100:1 ratio (see manufacturer’s instructions).

WARNING: Dipping the test panels in Proprietary Inhibitor and Cleaner solution without using a pressure rinse will not remove the embedded abrasive particles and the salts trapped in the corrosion pits but will only wet them, virtually guaranteeing premature coating failure. Using Proprietary Inhibitor and Cleaner both in the blast and wash down cycles is a failsafe method to obtain maximum cleanliness of the substrate. After the wash down cycle is completed, allow the test panels to dry, usually 15-30 minutes, before they are coated or subjected to any other test. Failure to allow the surface to dry will also lead to premature coating failure. Understandably, for test purposes, higher than recommended concentrations may be used. The greater the concentration, the longer the drying time, but under no circumstances should a coating be applied over a wet or damp surface.

For UHP Water Jetting, waterjetting, water blasting (water with little or no abrasive at 25,000+ p.s.i.)

Typically chemicals are NOT used in the BLAST CYCLE.

Blast cycle: (optional) (applicable if, and only if, pump manufacturer approves.) Start with 250:1 Proprietary Inhibitor and Cleaner. If flash occurs, decrease water portion (increase portion) until there is no flash.

Wash down (rinse) cycle: Begin as soon as practical after the blast. If Proprietary Inhibitor and Cleaner was used in blast cycle, start with 200:1. If Proprietary Inhibitor and Cleaner was not used in blast cycle, start with 100:1. (In either case, wash downwater pressure should be at least 500 p.s.i. with a water flow rate of at least 2 g.p.m..). If the surface is highly contaminated with chlorides and/or the water is very hard (contains elevated levels of carbonates or bicarbonates) and/or the surface is deeply pitted or profiled and/or weather conditions are marginal, it may be necessary to decrease water and increase Proprietary Inhibitor and Cleaner from the recommended start ratios to 100:1 or 50:1, respectively.

For Dry Abrasive Blasting (wash down only, of course) Start with 50:1. Wash down pressure should be no less than 500 p.s.i. at 2+ g.p.m. 1,500+ p.s.i. is highly recommended to totally remove the dust and contaminants from the anchor profile. Then increase water portion (or decrease Proprietary Inhibitor and Cleaner ) until flash appears or appears before you wish it to (i.e., until your blast window is unsatisfactory.)

Three most critical points for wash downs:

1. Always use the appropriate ratio of Proprietary Inhibitor and Cleaner for the specific blasting application with potable water.

2. Always use recommended minimum pressure and flow corresponding to the blasting application used.

3. Do not dip in or brush the surface with Proprietary Inhibitor and Cleaner as a substitute for a pressurized rinse..

RECOMMENDED COATING TESTS: Test panels prepared in the earlier section can now be subjected to the following tests. These are ASTM tests, approved and recommended by both SSPC and NACE. Coating compatibility approvals of Proprietary Inhibitor and Cleaner from several coating manufacturer’s i.e. Sherwin-Williams, Carboline, Ameron, PPG, Tnemec, etc. are based on the result of these tests (please see Representative Coating Compatibility Chart). Some tests were completed at the coating company’s laboratory and some of them were conducted at an independent laboratory under the supervision of coating company corrosion specialist. The test results are available on request.

1. ASTM D 5894 – 96 Standard Practice for Cyclic Salt Fog / UV Exposure of Painted Metal, (Alternating Exposures in a Fog / Dry Cabinet and a UV / Condensation Cabinet)

2. ASTM D 4541 – 95 Standard Test Method for Pull-Off Strength of Coatings Using Portable Adhesion Testers

3. ASTM D 610 – 95 Standard Test Method for Evaluating Degree of Rusting on Painted Steel Surfaces

4. ASTM D 714 – 87 Standard Test Method for Evaluating Degree of Blistering of Paints

5. ASTM D 1654 – 92 Standard Test Method for Evaluation of Painted or Coated Specimens Subjected to Corrosive Environments

RECOMMENDED CHLORIDE REMOVAL TESTS: The following tests are recommended if the panels are tested for soluble salts or any other contaminant which Proprietary Inhibitor and Cleaner may effectively remove. These test are also described in SSPC-TU 4 – Field Methods for Retrieval and Analysis of Soluble Salts on Substrates.

1. ISO 8502-6 Bresle Sampling Method, (SSPC-TU 4, Section 3.3 – Adhesively Bonded Cell)

2. ISO 8502-5 Chloride Ion Detection Tube (SSPC-TU 4, Section 4.3 – Field Detection of Chloride Ion by Kitigawa Tube)

3. ISO 8502-1 Field Test for Iron II Salts in Abrasive Blast Cleaned Surfaces (Field Test for Soluble Iron Corrosion Products) (SSPC-TU 4, Section 4.8 Qualitative Field Detection of Ferrous Ion)

4. Quantab Strip (SSPC-TU 4, Section 4.4 – Field Detection of Chlorine Ion by Quantab Method)

Example of Heavy Flash Rust Swatch

Example of Moderate Flash Rust Swatch:

034-swatch-wipe-heavy-flash-rust035-swatch-wipe-heavy-flash-rust

036-swatch-wipe-heavy-flash-rust

 Easy to prepare the swatches.
 Keeps a constant light pressure.
 Gives a clear distinction between light, moderate, and heavy.
 The color transfers to only the cloth that is in contact with the surface. It can be difficult to interpret the various spots of color.

Wipe or Sweep with Cloth Held in Hand

Wipe or Sweep with a Cloth held in a hand


 Make a bundle of cloth in your hand.
 Swipe the dry cloth across the surface.
 Make one swipe, up or down or sideways with the cloth touching the surface.
 Try to avoid pressing the fingers against the surface.

The following four pictures are examples of hand held wips and light flash rust.

012-hand-rag-wipe-light-flash-rust

013-hand-rag-wipe-light-flash-rust

014-hand-rag-wipe-light-flash-rust

015-hand-rag-wipe-light-flash-rust-effect-of-sun-angle

Close up of two Light Flash Rust cloths.

016-hand-rag-wipe-light-flash-rust-fingertips-on-cloth

017-hand-rag-wipe-light-flash-rust

In the two pictures above, the top one shows transference where the fingertips met the surface. There might be some color, but not much.